The Casper Mattress is good for people who want a medium-firm mattress that will cradle their body and relieve pressure. The Saatva Mattress is better for people who want an innerspring bed with three different firmness options to choose from.
Saatva is one of the most highly-rated options for an innerspring hybrid mattress and Casper is a high-quality memory foam option.
Both mattresses are in the same price range, but which brand you choose to go with will depend on a variety of factors. We hope to make your decision easier by going into some detail on the construction of each mattress, their firmness, warranty information, and more.
4 Reasons to Pick the Casper or Saatva Mattress:
Choose the Casper Mattress If:
- You need targeted lumbar support: The Casper mattress has a firmer section at your hips and core, offering targeted support. If you suffer from sore hips or back, this type of support could really make a difference.
- You get hot in your sleep: Casper uses an open-cell foam that helps to keep air flowing and prevents the sleeper from overheating. If you struggle with waking up sweaty in the night, this might be a welcome change.
- You sleep with a partner: Since Casper is an all-foam bed, it does better than some other mattress materials at absorbing motion. People who sleep with a restless partner or a pet will have better luck staying asleep with a bed like this.
Choose the Saatva Mattress If:
- You want three firmness options: While the Casper mattress comes in just one firmness level, the Saatva mattress gives you three options. This allows you to choose a more customized bed for the best possible sleep.
- You want a bed with a bouncy feel: Since Saatva uses coils in its construction, it has more of a traditional springy feel to it than the Casper mattress. If you know you like this feeling, it could be a good choice for you.
- You want a luxurious pillow top: Sleepers who know they enjoy the feeling of a soft pillow top in their bed will appreciate Saatva. This layer helps with pressure relief and overall comfort.
Casper is an all-foam bed with four layers, totaling 9.5 inches in height. The top layer is 1.5 inches of open-cell foam, which promotes airflow to ensure the sleeper doesn’t overheat at night. Next is a 1.5-inch layer of contouring foam that creates the signature cradling hug sensation memory foam is known for.
Under that is 1.5 inches of transition foam that provides hip support by not allowing your body to sink too deeply into the top layers. Finally, is a 5-inch high-density foam base layer that prevents sagging and gives the mattress its shape.
Saatva is a completely different type of mattress than Casper, using both foam and two layers of coils in its construction. This mattress starts with an organic cotton cover, followed by a pillow top for comfort.
The pillow top has a thin memory foam layer under it for an extra plush feel and is followed by an inch of memory foam and a coil layer for support. According to Saatva, this is the layer that provides the most support, encouraging natural alignment in the sleeper. The foundation layer of the bed is made from tempered steel coils for additional firm support and durability.
Firmness and Support
Casper comes in just one firmness level: Medium-Firm. The bed is soft enough to create cradling sinkage but firm enough to feel properly supported while lying on it.
Medium-firm mattresses are most suitable for the widest range of people since they’re comfortable for every sleeping position. The bed has a bit of bounce to it, even though it doesn’t use coils.
The Saatva mattress has three different comfort options: Plush Soft, Luxury Firm, and Firm.
Plush Soft: The Plush Soft is a 3/10 in terms of firmness and works best for side sleepers since this sleeping position tends to put pressure on the hips and shoulders, requiring a soft surface for comfort. A soft bed like this can also work for people who don’t weigh much, as they won’t sink in too far and should feel properly and comfortably supported.
Luxury Firm: The Luxury Firm option by Saatva is their most popular model and has a 6/10 firmness level. Since it has a medium-firm feel, it’s suitable for all sleep positions and body types.
Firm: The firmest model by Saatva, this bed is an 8/10 on the firmness scale. Firm beds are best for people who are carrying some extra weight or those who sleep exclusively on their backs. Back sleeping is best with a firm mattress because it keeps the spine in proper alignment, instead of allowing the hips to sink in too far.
Comfort and Temperature
Temperature is an important factor when it comes to sleep quality. Sleeping cold is an easy problem to fix with a thick blanket, but sleeping warm can be a bit more complicated. If you sleep too hot, it can cause sweating and discomfort, pulling you out of a deep sleep.
Waking up repeatedly in the night can cause you to wake up feeling exhausted, so ensuring that the bed you choose has cooling properties will prevent this from happening. Let’s look at the steps both Casper and Saatva have taken in this department.
Casper has a supportive, comfortable feel to their mattress, which creates a cradling hug and allows the sleeper to sink in. While some all-foam beds have an issue with retaining heat, Casper has taken steps to address this common problem.
The top layer has an open-cell design that helps to disperse extra heat from the bed. In addition, it has a breathable cover that feels cool and comfortable to the touch. These factors combined help the mattress keep air circulating, so you won’t wake up hot and sweaty.
The Saatva bed is a luxurious mattress that envelops the sleeper in a gentle hug, supporting the lumbar area with contouring foam. The pillow top is made from a breathable material designed to keep the sleeper resting comfortably.
Since the Saatva mattress uses two innerspring layers, it keeps air flowing and prevents too much heat or moisture from building up in the bed.
Warranty and Return Policies
When you buy a new mattress, one of the first factors you should consider is the company’s warranty. You’ll need to know how long it’s valid for and how it addresses manufacturing errors and general wear and tear over the years. Here are some warranty terms from both Casper and Saatva.
Casper has a 100-night sleep trial for their bed that allows you to test it out and see if it’s the right mattress for you. If you choose not to keep the bed, you can request a return, get a refund, and the company will donate the bed to charity or recycle it.
Casper offers a standard 10-year warranty for their mattress, which covers structural damage and manufacturing defects. Using the wrong foundation with the bed will make the warranty void, so keep that in mind. If you return the Casper mattress, the company will cover replacement or repair costs, although handling and transport fees may apply.
Saatva has a 120-night sleep trial period that begins as soon as the bed has been delivered to your place. If you’re dissatisfied with the bed and choose to return it, they’ll refund your money and pick the mattress up. The Saatva mattress comes with two warranty options: prorated and the Fair Replacement Option (non-prorated) warranty. Let’s look a bit closer at each.
Non-prorated standard warranty: Under the 15-year standard non-prorated warranty by Saatva, the company will cover replacement or repair costs as specified in the warranty conditions. You won’t owe anything for the first two years you own the mattress, although you will have to pay a $99 shipping cost each way for replacements or repairs from years three to 15 of owning the bed.
Fair Replacement Option: The other coverage option offered by Saatva is a prorated warranty called the Fair Replacement Option. This also lasts 15 years and makes it simpler for you to request a new bed, should you need one. If you decide to replace your bed within the first two years, the company will replace it for free (excluding the $99 fee for shipping).
If you return it between years three and five, you’ll owe 25 percent of the original mattress cost, 50 percent between years six and 10, and 75 percent of the cost between years 11 and 15.
Shipping and Delivery
Online shopping is becoming more and more popular these days and that includes mattress shopping. This cuts down time spent at the store and comes with the advantage of finding products any time of the day or night. Also, online retailers don’t have to pay for showroom costs which can make buying a mattress on the Internet cheaper.
Lots of companies offer free or affordable shipping and a money-back guarantee in case you’re dissatisfied with your purchase. Some mattress manufacturers even offer setup options and will remove your old mattress or the packaging waste from the new one. Here are some shipping and delivery terms to be familiar with before ordering either the Casper or Saatva mattress.
Each mattress from Casper is made to order, so you’ll have to plan for a few days for the manufacturing process before they’ll deliver your new bed. You can expect delivery to take up to seven days. The brand ships to all 50 states, including Hawaii and Alaska, for free.
They use UPS standard delivery for their mattresses and select U.S. cities have White Glove Delivery available. This means that the professionals from Casper will help you set up your new bed when they deliver it.
Saatva also ships to all 50 states, though they charge a $99 transport cost. Although this seems expensive compared to other manufacturers that give customers free shipping, it includes both delivery and setup. This is especially beneficial for people who live by themselves as setting up a mattress alone can be difficult or impossible, particularly when stairs are involved.
If you need to have your old bed taken away, it will cost an additional $39. You can expect between seven and 15 business days for your new Saatva mattress, so plan accordingly.
One of the first questions anyone will have when they’re buying a new mattress is how much it will cost them. A number of factors will impact price, including the durability of materials and how well-known the brand name is.
Both Casper and Saatva sell quality mattresses for less than what you would expect to pay from a brick-and-mortar store. Saatva is a bit more expensive than Casper, although they are technically in the same price range. The Casper Mattress costs $995 for a Queen size and the Saatva Mattress is currently priced at $1,099.
Finding a non-toxic bed that is healthy for both the environment and you can be a hard task and it’s fairly unsettling that so many companies use harsh chemicals and flame retardants in their mattresses. Looking at environmental certifications and the quality of materials used in the mattress you’re considering can help ease your mind about this.
Casper uses CertiPUR-US® certified foams, meaning that the materials have been tested to ensure they’re free from harmful levels of toxic chemicals. You can also be assured that their foams are free from heavy metals or formaldehyde.
Saatva uses 30 percent plant-based foams in their mattress instead of entirely synthetic materials. This can be less irritating for the sleeper and also safer for the environment. They use organic cotton in their covers and recycled tempered steel while working to reduce their carbon footprint.
Motion transfer is when one person moves around in bed and the vibrations disturb the other sleeper. Most people move around in their sleep, so sharing a bed with a partner can cause these disturbances throughout the night, compromising your overall quality of rest. Here’s how each mattress rates in this category:
The Casper Mattress is an all-foam bed, which means it’s top of the line at absorbing motion. The surface of the bed was designed to provide some bounce but also isolate motion well, so partners can share it comfortably.
While innerspring beds aren’t as good as foam beds at isolating motion, they can still perform well in this category if they have individually wrapped coils and layers of foam like the Saatva bed. If you have a partner and you both want a traditional bed with springs but also need some motion isolation, the Saatva Mattress could work for you.
Overall, it’s hard to say whether the Casper mattress or Saatva mattress is better because it truly depends on you. Casper is good for people with any body type who want a medium-firm bed that provides a deep hug but also has targeted lumbar support.
The Saatva mattress might work better for people who are carrying some extra weight, like the more traditional mattress feel, and need the durable support of coils. It’s also good for sleepers who want three comfort levels to choose from and a bouncy bed with a plush pillow top.